The crash of Germanwings Flight 4U9525 is a truly tragic situation. In light of some of the emerging details regarding the pilot’s mental health, many will make false assumptions about depression and other mental illnesses and connect them to violent behavior; assumptions that are not based on science or statistics. Negative or inaccurate comments about mental illness seen in media coverage and on social networks will only serve to push those experiencing symptoms of mental illness further away from an open dialogue with their friends and family, or the potential for successful treatment. It’s important that we continue to work to end the prejudice against mental illness so that those who are hurting will seek help and not hide their pain for fear of judgement, isolation, or job loss.
A number of good articles and statements have been released about this tragedy as it relates to our discussion about mental health. If you have any to add to our list, please leave us a comment.
Mental Health America Mourns Victims of Germanwings Flight
Andreas Lubitz depression headlines add to stigma
Mind’s response to today’s front pages on the Germanwings plane crash
SAMH and See Me Joint Statement on Germanwings Flight 9525
Comment on media reporting of Germanwings plane crash from Time to Change
Lessons From The Germanwings Crash: We Need to Stop Stigmatizing Mental Health
*Newly added* Exploring differences between depression and the actions of the pilot Thank you, Wendy, for contributing this article!
Whether you pop in the DVD or catch one of the many showings on television this season, the Frank Capra classic “It’s a Wonderful Life” tops many must-watch lists for holiday viewing. But for those of you who work in crisis and suicide prevention we suspect you view this film through a unique lens…
You know you’re a Crisis Worker watching “It’s a Wonderful Life” if…
- You comment on how the movie perpetuates the myth that suicide rates go up at Christmastime
- You’re jealous that Clarence got to see a factual recap of George’s life before talking to him and think about how much that would help you respond to callers
- You know George’s circumstances aren’t nearly as bad as many of the people you’ve talked to, and yet you still empathize with him and don’t judge him for feeling suicidal
- You can list all the warning signs that George is giving, and yell at the other characters for not picking up on them
- Even better, you wish someone would talk to George about his behavior and ask him directly if he was thinking of suicide
- You praise Mary for calling a family member to talk about how George was behaving, and not keeping his behavior a secret
- It reminds you of all the people you’ve spoken to that thought their suicide would be what’s best for their family
- You note that George chose a very high lethality method
- You wish Clarence would spend more time letting George tell him how he’s feeling and what has him thinking about suicide, instead of shutting him down and telling George he shouldn’t say such things
- You’re relieved when George finds his reasons for living
- You’re thankful for the happy ending, but you know that it’s rarely wrapped up so easily
- You’re reminded of why you do the work you do
Have you had any of these thoughts while watching this classic film? Got any other thoughts to add? We’d love to hear from you, leave us a comment!
And while you may not have wings, we know the countless individuals touched by your caring voices consider you all guardian angels. Thank you for your hard work and dedication to saving lives, during the holidays and all year round.
Like so many others, we’re deeply saddened by the death of famous actor and comedian Robin Williams. His death, preliminarily declared a suicide by local authorities, comes as a shock to many who knew him as a comedic genius who brought laughter and joy to millions. While he openly discussed his drug and alcohol addictions and commitment to sobriety, he never publicly acknowledged any diagnosis of depression or other mental illness. His publicist and friends, however, have shared that he was “battling severe depression” and in Tuesday’s press conference authorities said he was seeking treatment for depression.
This tragic and untimely death of someone known and loved by millions has started a dialogue about mental illness and suicide. Since the announcement of Robin Williams’ death and the way he died, there has been an outpouring of support, discussion about mental illness and addictions, words of encouragement, and sharing of important suicide prevention resources and numbers to call for help, the most common being the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline.
To aid in this important discussion and opportunity for education, we’d like to share with you this blog by Hollis Easter, Hotline Coordinator for Reachout of St. Lawrence County, Inc. and suicide prevention educator.
And while we’re educating others about how to positively contribute to these discussions, let’s talk about that common saying: “Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.” People who say this surely mean well and are only trying to help. Perhaps they think they’ve found that magic phrase that will speak to the person who they want to help and get that person to “snap out of it.” The truth is that most people who attempt suicide were not doing so as a permanent solution to a temporary problem; they wanted a permanent end to weeks, months, or years of personal torment and agony, often due to a medical condition. To say that it’s a temporary issue greatly minimalizes the deep pain and very real suffering they are going through, and likely have been going through for some time.
For more thoughts on why this turn of phrase should be avoided, check out another recent blog by Hollis titled
It is our hope that out of this loss, more people will be educated on the topics of suicide and mental illness. And while a flurry of media attention was placed on Mr. Williams’ death it’s important to note that on Monday an estimated 10 Canadians and 107 more Americans (108 including Mr. Williams) also died by suicide. Each of these deaths is tragic and leaves in its wake at least six people deeply devastated by their loss.
If you work in the suicide prevention industry: Thank you. Your patience, empathy, and compassion is a true gift and you’ve surely touched more lives than you may realize. Whether you speak directly with those contemplating suicide on a hotline, educate others on warning signs and intervention methods, or play one of the numerous other roles in the industry, the work you do saves lives.